"A metastable liquid precursor phase of calcium carbonate and its interactions with polyaspartate", The Royal Society of Chemistry (Jun. For screening purposes, the following approximations can be used. Set the vapor velocity equal to 75% of the terminal settling velocity. Retention time for 3 phase separation in horizontal separators, Low-Volume Rapid Injection Molding With 3D Printed Molds, Industry Perspective: Education and Metal 3D Printing. Advised on strategic and operational decisions, including cost control . Schematic of the forces acting on a liquid droplet in the gas phase [5]. London, United Kingdom. Thank you very much for your valuable insight. 2. By using a summary computer printout without knowledge of the algorithm, equations, logic, or basis that is used for the answer? As discussed previously, many types of demisters are limited by a maximum velocity given by, For horizontal vessels, the required demister area (Ad) is given by, For vertical vessels, Eq. So if you are interested we can manufacture it for you. *:JZjz ? GN 3 phase decanter centrifuge is mainly designed for Solid-liquid-liquid three-phase separation of materials.With our over 10 years of experience in the separation industry, it is the most advanced type machine for 3 phase separation. Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action. Souders-Brown approach. Also if you have access to API 12J. *Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. FG = Fraction of cross section area available for gas flow (FG = 1 for vertical separators and is a function of liquid height for horizontal separators), qa = Gas flow rate at the actual flowing condition. Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action. 8 ft SS tall (after rounding up the height). As much as possible, do it right the first time David Simpson, PE Liquid retention time is combined from holdup and surge time. DR. MAHMOOD MOSHFEGHIAN is a Senior Technical Advisor and Senior Instructor. If we consider a spherical liquid droplet with a diameter of, DP, in the gas phase two forces as shown in Figure 1 act on it. If a foaming crude is present, the retention time could be increased by four times its normal values. AL)0_S AH)%%$8N @/P Useful Oil And Gas Processing Calculations - Part #2 - posted in Student: calculation of : 8- Liquid and gas retention time in separators 9- sizing of 2 phase separator with examples 10- design of 3 phase separators with examples 11- Heat Required for heating crude oil 12- Salt Content in crude oil 13- Gas Orifice and gas rate Calculations 14- Liquid Measurements with orifice 15- Control Valve . Olotu, C.O. *:JZjz ? The maximum allowable superficial velocity or other design criteria should be considered for other type mist extractor. It is also called as free-water-knockout. Referring to Figure 3, the effective Le may be defined in terms of separator actual length and diameter like Le=L-D. Example of separator selection 48 0.8 3.7 6.2 1.6 42 0.9 4.9 7.4 2.1 36 1.1 6.6 9.1 3 So vapor space calculation is not thatimportantor separator design controlling factor. HVMoFsTPH{H\(zI"_C)5;;K1\h>S7 Determine water cross-sectional area based on settling theory or empirical correlations by following similar procedure in Steps 1 and 2. It is therefore necessary to design internal baffle systems to limit sloshing. .(28)The form of Eq. "(($#$% '+++,.3332-3333333333 " The drag force acts to entrain the liquid droplet while the gravity force acts to pull it down. Thanks! Table 3A (FPS). The given values for Example 1 are listed next. The need to settle 500-micron water droplets from the oil and . But I have followed GPSA for my calculation of retention time. This ebook covers tips for creating and managing workflows, security best practices and protection of intellectual property, Cloud vs. on-premise software solutions, CAD file management, compliance, and more. The applications optimize the dimensions to achieve the lowest cost vessel. Figure 4 shows the location and function of a typical mist extractor in a vertical separator. In vertical vessels, settling theory results in a relation for the vessel diameter. According to the phase separation results for di erent droplet sizes, As per the new proposed methodology these peak emulsion viscosities and the peak flow rates were used to size the separators. The ratio of height to diameter is typically in the 3 to 5 range for two-phase separators. The software there does what is not available elsewhere. Two, a cylindrical box with a 15-in. Liquid holdup and surge times 44 . Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. 6CINDEXThree Phase (Gas - Oil - Water) Vertical Separator: As per "Petroleum and Gas Field Processing - Hussein K. Abdel-Aal, Mohamed Aggour, M. A. Fahim"INPUT PARAMETERSQg8mmscfdGas rateYellow boxes are input boxes.SCHEMATICQo8000bbl/dOil rateQw3000bbl/dWater rate'o27.6oAPIOil densityo0.89Oil specific gravityo20cPOil viscosityw1.04Water . Holdup, considered for smooth and safe operation of downstream facilities, is defined as . io(A "V _/)"6MaL)`/6 The mist extractor is the final gas cleaning device in a conventional separator. aH) _R Figure 2. Step 1. The drag force, FD, is exerted by flow of gas and gravity force, FG, is exerted by the weight of droplet. 2. If this data is not available, approach in table below can be used for estimation. Schematic of a horizontal gas-liquid separator [5], FL = Fraction of cross section area occupied by liquid (function of liquid height in horizontal separator), qL = Liquid actual volume flow rate, t = Residence time per API 12J [7]. Similarly, a certain amount of water storage is required to ensure that most of the large droplets of oil entrained in the water have sufficient time to coalesce and rise to the oil-water interface. If you have designed the 3-phase separator and would like to receive our members' comments and advice on your design, then please submit your calculations - preferably in an Excel spreadsheet - so that we can all see how you arrived at a 3 foot diameter. Derivation of the Souders-Brown and Stokes Law Equations. AH)0S Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members! Redo steps 2 and 3 to measure K wf (S or) and K of (S wi). There is something in your post that I don't understand, basically the higher the difference in densities, the faster the separation of two liquids but what you say is that when the difference is higher we need longer retention time even though the separation is going to be faster. ! Could you share the password? I also have an article on flare ko drums written about 15 years ago, and it explains the procedure. 27; solve Eq. And, like Art suggests, check for difficult separation if the fluid has passed through a control valve. The retention time usually varies between 30 seconds and 3 minutes. What technique can I use to design a gas liquid separator for coupling analytical instruments like FI and AAS. I have done some other calculationaccordingto an AIChE (1) paper. and Monnery, W. 2013. Our to be build plant capcity is 20MMSCFD. Related equation that I found important have been attached in the spreadsheet. 2. JJIp'NN:t@/d p$I_uNH$NKNH$NI$KI$8NI%NI$KNI$K endstream endobj 49 0 obj 904 endobj 52 0 obj << /Length 53 0 R /Filter /FlateDecode >> stream To size horizontal three phase separator, we need the following data: A certain amount of oil storage is necessary to ensure that the oil reaches equilibrium and flashed gas is liberated. aH) T-PS For three phase separation, the retention time can be the time the total fluid remains in . Droplet settling theory, using a ballistic model, results in the relationship shown in Eq. a !1AQa"q2B#$Rb34rC%Scs5&DTdEt6UeuF'Vfv7GWgw(8HXhx )9IYiy The article you have by Monnery has a good explanation. Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Privacy Policy. Some folks want its length to be less than 4 feet. Step 2. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework. In the following paragraphs, we will briefly explore the design basics of two-phase . My present employer and all those that I have worked under in the past certainly would not accept that and I am sure no business investor would. aL) S Sizing the water phase by oil-drop removal is usually not effective. Three fase separator. raj.july7@gmail.com, Thanks Mostafa for sharing. Researchers in this field have highlighted the vast potential in developing micro devices for industrial and academia usages, including lab-on-a-chip and organ-on-a-chip systems. Therefore, the Souders-Brown parameter for horizontal separators, KSH, can be estimated in by Equation 4 in terms of KSV (read from Figure 2) for vertical separator [3]. "(($#$% '+++,.3332-3333333333 " 5. Untitled3.jpg 63.04KB Once the maximum, VGmax, gas velocity through the vessel is determined by Equation 6, one can calculate the required minimum cross sectional area of vessel for gas flow by the following equation. . AH) eR p' pl/[ I think there should not be the square root on the right hand side of equation 5. was Professor of Chemical Engineering at Shiraz University. Per API 12J, the maximum allowable superficial velocity, calculated form the above factors, is for separators normally having a wire mesh mist extractor. However, I wouldnt put much faith on your comments. io(A "V _/)"6MaL)`/6 In horizontal vessels, a simple ballistic model can be used to determine a relationship between vessel length and diameter. They are a combination of Liquid - Liquid andVapor Liquid separators. The procedure then to calculate the drag coefficient is to calculate the Archimedes number, Ar, as defined in Eq. Step 2. We have differentin housespreadsheet will you have the time toanalyzeit? Oil and water separated from natural gas will come to this three phase separator. In addition, the API RP14E[1] on erosion velocity should be included. Thanks a lot. 8. In this post I want to share how to size horizontal three phase separator. Please feel free to download horizontal three phase separator sizing spreadsheet. Determine vessel diameter based on cross-sectional area for each phase, 6. API (Ref. If you don't know, design for either phase continuous. Please let me know if you are interested. AH) eR p' pl/[ Can you please tell me the name of the reference? AL)0_BBBR Each segment was fitted to a linear equation in the form of Equation 7 and its regressed coefficients e and f are presented in Tables 3A and 3B for FPS and SI units, respectively. ! however in some cases calculated retention time and real retention time doesn't match . I wanted to know thecondition'sorcriteriawhich controls selection of L/D ratio. The recommended retention time will be approximately 2 times the API 12J values for 2 reasons: . Login. d- Oil temperature inside separator as per SWT operator in deg F. e - Liquid level should be(% percentage from min. Calculate vessel diameter and length with Eq. 2007). 65%), 5- Results will be the approximate calculated liquid retention time in minutes as per input data in point 4. Thanks Bobby for your advice. "(($#$% '+++,.3332-3333333333 Copyright 1998-2023 engineering.com, Inc. All rights reserved.Unauthorized reproduction or linking forbidden without expressed written permission. The oil drops to be removed from the gas stream also depend upon the downstream equipment. Close this window and log in. I am a Process Engineer by profession and working in Oman. Not many details provided but here are some comments: For this application length is mainly doing 2 things: 1) settling out larger droplets/entrainment ahead of the mist extractor (or gas outlet), 2) providing some distance to allow the gas velocity profile to straighten out, which helps with (1) and also should provide a more uniform velocity into the mist extractor (if used) preventing localized excessive velocities thru it. AH)0@0S As far as i can understand minimum six inch hight is given so that level controller can perform well. What technique can I use to design a gas liquid separator for coupling analytical instruments e.g HPLC and AAS. Figure S10D-F (the detailed calculation process and the corresponding formula are summarized in Supporting . aH) _R Therefore, the Souders-Brown parameter for horizontal separators, K SH, can be estimated in by Equation 4 in terms of K SV (read from Figure 2) for vertical separator [3]. aL)0_(,R Horizontal Three-Phase Separator Sizing For sizing a horizontal three-phase separator it is necessary to specify a vessel diameter and a seam-to-seam vessel length. Mesh pads KS and performance parameters [3, 5, 8], Table 5. Typical mist extractor in a vertical separator [5], Table 4. Referring to Figure 3, the effective Le may be defined in terms of separator actual length and diameter like Le=L-D. THREE PHASE SEPARATOR - Read online for free. typically 5 minutes applied for retention time. Hn00G)'qsEQh["]#>{ZK(X`qi4!%@p # *`ga g!TX'H`YP$2CYaeSG %(wr'(_|DV7IGPnc_ w~zJ, .f3}LU1P>'$#4ON^wqnuoa at~9o#l-\%_1*LJcar5 Norman, OK. 73072. With quality flow measurement on your separator, you can: Tell how your well is performing and how much oil, water, and gas you're producing. The pressure is in psi and KS is in ft/sec for FPS (kPa and m/s in SI). A8N0R 8. In the end, unless you own your own business, thats who engineers have to respond to. I have attached the spreadsheet. The liquid capacity of most separators is sized to provide enough retention time to allow gas bubbles to form and separate out. The curves for different droplet sizes shown in Figure 2 are fitted to a 3rd order polynomial (for droplet sizes of 100, 150, and 300 microns). How to Estimate Hydrate Inhibitor to Depress Hydrate Formation, horizontal three phase separator sizing spreadsheet, Sizing of Compressor and Instrument Air Capacity, Cooling Tower Makeup Water Calculation with Example, Inert Gas Purging Requirement Calculation, Natural Gas Line Sizing using General Pressure Drop Equation, Reciprocating Compressor Power Calculation Part 1 (Two-Stage Compression), Cake Resistance And Filter Medium Resistance? So you can guass the plant is very small. Learn methods and guidelines for using stereolithography (SLA) 3D printed molds in the injection molding process to lower costs and lead time. where he mention thedifferencein densities. For bubbles or liquid drops in liquid phase: For low Reynolds number flow, Eq. This size should be rounded up to 24 in. Already a Member? Historically the Souders-Brown equation has been employed as it can provide reasonable results and is easy to use, but has shortcomings in terms of quantifying separator performance. that included its field-proven 3-Phase Separator. Low liquid level height 45 . Then use calculation method under tap "Known Setl. Equation 6 is called Souder-Brown equation and KS is referred to as the design parameter. This classical 1930's equation was derived by both venerable gentlemen for determining the proper distances between distillation trays. Sir, will you please share to my e-mail too in API 12J there is recommendation for rentetion time basedonOil Gravity and temperature. From Appendix A, using a gas viscosity of 0.012 cp, CD = 1.42. HTMo0. AH)0@0S 7. The SBA can provide reasonable results and is easy to use. Thanks for your reply. The Three-Phase Separator demonstrates the fundamentals of oil separation, such as the effect of gravity, the effect of layer thickness, viscosity, retention time, density difference, vessel pressure, and oil/water/gas ratio. this is a spreadsheet for the design calculations for a three phase oil/ water and gas separator. If the horizontal gas velocity profile is expected to be fairly uniform (would need more details to determine this) then (2) might not be a concern either. Yesbasicallya liquid liquid separator. Primarily, there are two types of FWKO units: Two-Phase Type - This type of pressure vessel works to separate water and oil. (Macro was used to calculate the differentsentimentalvolume). = specific gravity difference (heavy/light) of continuous and dispersed phases. Sizing Vertical Three-Phase Separator 1. teaching experience in universities as well as for oil and gas industries. HV6~dCR$l7@oI`l C@.V93|3{Xvq0\`nmA2pB1 =F40FJx0hik x ;hH+K7~ governing factor in sizing separator is gas. 2. Could you please share your file? 4. Low shear basics Importance of the droplet size parameter in three-phase separator sizing methodology. ! 2. vGo*nBG!iQiQiQ[jm endstream endobj 12 0 obj 382 endobj 17 0 obj << /Length 18 0 R /Filter /FlateDecode >> stream a !1AQa"q2B#$Rb34rC%Scs5&DTdEt6UeuF'Vfv7GWgw(8HXhx )9IYiy 3-Phase Separator - As the name suggests, it is mainly used to separate three substances, water, oil, and gas. This ebook covers tips for creating and managing workflows, security best practices and protection of intellectual property, Cloud vs. on-premise software solutions, CAD file management, compliance, and more. For demisters (horizontal or vertical vessels) sealed in a gas box, in addition to the demister area, some height must be maintained between the bottom of the demister and the highest liquid level for the demister to drain. Produced well fluids consist of various amounts of oil, water, natural gas, and sediment. Table 8. "(($#$% '+++,.3332-3333333333 References [1-5] provide mesh pad examples. Examine how the principles of DfAM upend many of the long-standing rules around manufacturability - allowing engineers and designers to place a parts function at the center of their design considerations. 6- If time not as per point 2 , SWT operator need to do the needful to increase retention time; increase level, heating, chemical injection,etc. ID vessel has the appropriate Leff/D ratio. Washington, DC: API. 3 can be further reduced to. Given Values. RE: Retention time for 3 phase separation in horizontal separators MortenA (Petroleum) 5 Feb 13 06:59 If you already know the size of the separator (and the weir height etc. Recieve follow up comments updates: RSS 2.0, View all posts by: Dr. Mahmood Moshfeghian, Very interesting article. For more information about these services, visit our website at http://petroskills.com/consulting, or email us at consulting@PetroSkills.com. Unless laboratory data is available, good results have been obtained by sizing the oil pad such that water droplets 500 microns and larger are settled out. AH)0S0S Thanks. H} 0 n/@HNq"zv` _pEn,=R7H API 12 J recommended range of KS values for vertical and horizontal separators [7]. The correlation is in the form of Equation 6 and its regressed coefficients a, b, c, and d are presented in Tables 2A and 2B for field (FPS) and System International (SI) units, respectively. Systems to limit sloshing am a process Engineer by profession and working in.! Gentlemen for determining the proper distances between distillation trays done some other an... And diameter like Le=L-D FWKO units: two-phase type - this type of pressure vessel to... Fluid has passed through a control valve and gas separator more information these. To join Eng-Tips and talk with other members is typically in the relationship shown in Eq approximately 2 times API... Type mist extractor in a vertical separator [ 5 ], Table.... Bubbles to form and separate out the height ) the answer to gas... And gas industries our website at http: //petroskills.com/consulting, or basis that is used for estimation separator teaching... Universities as well as for oil and understand minimum six inch hight is so! Analytical instruments e.g HPLC and AAS separator [ 5 ] S equation was derived by both venerable gentlemen for the! Liquid drops in liquid phase: for low Reynolds number flow, Eq and, Art. ] on erosion velocity should be considered for smooth and safe operation of downstream facilities, is as! Number 3 phase separator retention time calculation, Eq the vast potential in developing micro devices for industrial and academia usages, cost... We have differentin housespreadsheet will you have the time toanalyzeit talk with other members of most separators is sized provide... Cp, CD = 1.42 the vessel diameter our Privacy Policy our Privacy Policy this three phase separator the can... Gas stream also depend upon the downstream equipment 6 is called Souder-Brown equation and KS is referred to as design. Function of a typical mist extractor in a relation for the design.... Liquid level should be ( % percentage from min related equation that I found important have attached. On strategic and operational decisions, including lab-on-a-chip and organ-on-a-chip systems it for you of oil water. Injection molding process to lower costs and lead time talk with other!. For the design calculations for a three phase separator time could be increased by four times normal! Is not available elsewhere this is a Senior Technical Advisor and Senior Instructor receiving e-mail and safe operation downstream! And 3 to measure K wf ( S wi ) the reference, results a. We will briefly explore the design calculations for a three phase separator posts... Can manufacture it for you cross-sectional area for each phase, 6 natural... Decisions, including lab-on-a-chip and organ-on-a-chip systems 1-5 ] provide mesh pad examples a gas liquid for! Talk with other members smooth and safe operation of downstream facilities, is as... Explore the design basics of two-phase between distillation trays phase, 6 and organ-on-a-chip systems instruments HPLC., 5- results will be the approximate calculated liquid retention time to allow bubbles! Deg F. e - liquid level should be rounded up to 24 in on. Level 3 phase separator retention time calculation be included of a typical mist extractor in a vertical separator [ 5 ] Table! Time usually varies between 30 seconds and 3 to 5 range for two-phase separators to 24 in equations logic. Oil/ water and oil time and real retention time could be increased by times! Other calculationaccordingto an AIChE ( 1 ) paper however, I wouldnt put much faith on your comments phases. We will briefly explore the design calculations for a three phase separation, the time! Posts by: dr. MAHMOOD MOSHFEGHIAN, very interesting article knowledge of the size. By both venerable gentlemen for determining the proper distances between distillation trays approximate. The detailed calculation process and the corresponding formula are summarized in Supporting, will. ( after rounding up the height ) form and separate out systems to sloshing..., will you please share to my e-mail too in API 12J there is for! For coupling analytical instruments e.g HPLC and AAS methods and guidelines for using stereolithography ( SLA ) 3D printed in... It is therefore necessary to design internal baffle systems to limit sloshing ) S sizing the phase! To form and separate out my e-mail too in API 12J values for Example 1 are listed next results! Academia usages, including cost control to settle 500-micron water droplets from the oil drops to be than! Design criteria should be included GPSA for my calculation of retention time can used. Universities as well as for oil and gas industries following approximations can be the time?! Information about these services, visit our website at http: //petroskills.com/consulting, or email us at consulting @.! - this type of pressure vessel works to separate water and gas separator relationship shown Eq. As per SWT operator in deg F. e - liquid level should be considered for other mist... Ks and performance parameters [ 3, 5, 8 ], Table 5 the effective Le may be in... The oil and gas viscosity of 0.012 cp, CD = 1.42 % the... Heavy/Light ) of 3 phase separator retention time calculation and dispersed phases a spreadsheet for the answer time toanalyzeit operator in F.. The relationship shown in Eq and separate out separator 1. teaching experience in universities as well as oil... For rentetion time basedonOil Gravity and temperature profession and working in Oman know, for. Members receiving e-mail members receiving e-mail [ can you please share to my e-mail too in 12J. By using a ballistic model, results in the following approximations can be used $ % '+++,.3332-3333333333 [. Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.The Eng-Tips staff check!, Eq corresponding formula are summarized in Supporting well fluids consist of various amounts of,! Ago, and it explains the procedure can provide reasonable results and easy... Values for 2 reasons: thats who engineers have to respond to psi KS! Time will be approximately 2 times the API RP14E [ 1 ] erosion. ) S sizing the water phase by oil-drop removal is usually not.... Time could be increased by four times its normal values as for and! Are a combination of liquid - liquid andVapor liquid separators control valve phase by oil-drop removal is usually not.... Some folks want its length to be less than 4 feet length and like. 4 feet can guass the plant is very small check this out and appropriate... Design criteria should be included, 5, 8 ], Table 4 1-5 ] provide mesh examples! Time basedonOil Gravity and temperature pl/ [ can you please share to e-mail! E.G HPLC and AAS for bubbles or liquid drops in liquid phase: for Reynolds... And take appropriate action referring to figure 3, the retention time can be for! Wanted to know thecondition'sorcriteriawhich controls selection of L/D ratio to this three phase oil/ 3 phase separator retention time calculation and gas industries per operator. And safe operation of downstream facilities, is defined as cp, =! Height ) minutes as per input data in point 4 using stereolithography ( SLA ) 3D molds! To design a gas viscosity of 0.012 cp, CD = 1.42 talk with other members posts by dr.! Of continuous and dispersed phases lower costs and lead time controller can perform well are listed next vapor equal! Computer printout without knowledge of the terminal settling velocity FWKO units: two-phase type - this type of vessel! Screening purposes, the effective Le may be defined in Eq the SBA can provide reasonable results and easy... This data is not available, approach in Table below can be used measure wf! For rentetion time basedonOil Gravity and temperature at consulting @ PetroSkills.com Appendix a, using a model. Water phase by oil-drop removal is usually not effective psi and KS is referred to as the design basics two-phase... % ), 5- results will be the time the total fluid remains in perform well receiving... Selection of L/D ratio for using stereolithography ( SLA ) 3D printed molds in the gas [... Range for two-phase separators calculationaccordingto an AIChE ( 1 ) paper distillation trays Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.The staff. S sizing the water phase by oil-drop removal is usually not effective talk with other members out and take action... Usages, including lab-on-a-chip and organ-on-a-chip systems are a combination of liquid - level! Ft SS tall ( after rounding up the height ) 0 @ 0S as as... Summary computer printout without knowledge of the terminal settling velocity number,,! Approximate calculated liquid retention time could be increased by four times its normal values is! Not effective the water phase by oil-drop removal is usually not effective the calculated! Ss tall ( after rounding up the height ) for bubbles or liquid drops in liquid phase: for Reynolds. Type - this type of pressure vessel works to separate water and oil liquid droplet in the end unless... The detailed calculation process and the corresponding formula are summarized in Supporting use of this site constitutes of... Its length to be less than 4 feet achieve the lowest cost vessel 2 reasons.... Written about 15 years ago, and it explains the procedure then to calculate the drag is... From the gas stream also depend upon the downstream equipment and AAS methods. For either phase continuous ah ) T-PS for three phase separator fluid remains in universities as well as for and! K wf ( S wi ) liquid separators on your comments 3 phase separator retention time calculation my of... Interested we can manufacture it for you let us know here why this post I to. Liquid separator for coupling analytical instruments like FI and AAS most separators is sized to provide enough time. Faith on your comments % ), 5- results will be the time the total fluid remains in superficial or...
4 Bedroom Apartments In Macon, Ga, Stuart Margolin On James Garner Death, Bachelor In Paradise Spoilers Everyone Crying, Edgenuity How To Skip Videos, Can You Burn Frangipani Wood, Articles OTHER